Insight
OPS-0002 · 2026-11-18We stopped billing by the hour in 2019 and had to learn our costs
In 2004, I founded an IT service business from home in Hamburg, with only myself. It was billed on an hourly basis until 2019. From that point, our clients paid a flat monthly fee under rolling contracts that required one month's notice to cancel.
It took me a considerable amount of time to fully grasp the implications of the change. Probably longer than the decision itself. This is something that I think is commonly underestimated by small and medium-sized service businesses.
Why hourly billing no longer appealed to me
Hourly billing is a good thing for the service provider if there is lots of disruption to the client's IT. Downtime, failed backups, lockouts, etc., all generate additional revenue. I didn't feel this aligned with my ethos for the business. My explanation to clients when making this transition was: "If I have lots of failures, I'll be busy and make no money. Therefore I'm happy to have the same motivation as you."
A further challenge was that clients found it difficult to audit hourly billing. One client, a construction firm with about 150 employees, stated that their CFO would personally scrutinize our hourly billing. He was able to understand our simple three-tier hourly rate card, but did not feel able to audit the number of individual tickets.
This led us to offer clients a flat monthly rate on a monthly rolling contract (i.e., one month's notice to cancel). The assumption was that if the client elected to continue, they were satisfied with the service.
How this led to tracking profitability by client
Under hourly billing, revenue generally increased with the hours a client consumed. However, with a fixed monthly price, some clients could become unprofitable, and there was no easy way to identify them.
We could derive this information from three sources: the number of tickets/hours logged by each client on our ticketing platform, the amount billed to each client in our billing platform, and the residual margin shown in our monthly management accounts, known in Germany as a Betriebswirtschaftliche Auswertung (BWA), provided by our German tax advisor. Each source was accurate, but none individually could provide the full answer.
The resulting process was that we would download data from each source quarterly and reconcile in an Excel spreadsheet. Only one individual was able to do this. Clearly not ideal if we wanted to quickly establish if a client's contract remained viable (e.g., if they changed the size of their team) or if that individual was absent.
I therefore built a basic script to merge the various datasets. This became the basis for Yupana. For others making the same transition, I would suggest identifying a mechanism to calculate client profitability and ensuring this can be readily derived by multiple individuals.
One caveat: Be careful of false confidence in an incorrect profitability number. Better to rely on intuition if you have no visibility than assume you know when the information is flawed. Ensure that tickets are being logged to the correct client and that your data sources are measuring the same thing (e.g., users versus machines).
Is monthly fixed rate suitable for all engagements?
No, I would only apply this to recurring services where you can define the scope. We used an initial fixed fee for a review of the client's requirements to determine an appropriate monthly rate. Otherwise, you run the risk of either the client benefiting from an underestimated quote or you absorbing the difference.
I appreciate that there are advantages to hourly rates, particularly for non-recurring work or to prevent abuse by a client who exceeds expectations. It should also be noted that month-to-month contracts can create a cash flow risk to the provider.
Nonetheless I remain convinced that monthly fixed pricing creates better alignment between service provider and client, provided you are happy to monitor client profitability.
Key considerations prior to transition to fixed fee
I would analyze at least one year of historical tickets and associated time to be able to map against historical billing for each client, and identify if any would be unprofitable at the intended rate.
Clarify what your pricing is based on (number of users, machines, seats, etc.), and ensure it is defined in client-facing documentation, as it can vary significantly for a given client.
Review actual profitability of clients on a regular cadence (e.g., quarterly) versus your assumed target, and ensure that this is an owned task. My message to clients at this stage was, "As a business, owner you wouldn't want your costs to be open-ended, nor would we!" While this addresses the client's concerns, it means that the business needs to monitor its costs per client.
This article was first published on Featured News.
